Neuroscience

The Neurocinema Collection™

First poster for Joseph Kahn's adaptation of William Gibson's Neuromancer?

The term "neurocinema" has been in the news lately. What does it mean? Movies with the prefix "neuro" somewhere in the title?

Titles (20 Approx Matches)

		Neuro (2004)
		Neurosia - 50 Jahre pervers (1995) aka "Neurosia-Fifty Years of Perversion" - USA aka "Neurosia" - Germany (short title) aka "Neurosia - Who Shot Rosa von Praunheim" - USA (video box title)
		Labyrinth (1959) aka "Neurose" - Italy
		Revenge in the House of Usher (1982) aka "Neurosis"
		Neuromancer (2011)

Movies having to do with neurology, such as the NEURO CINEMA FESTIVAL sponsored by the San Francisco Neurological Society?

Awakenings (encephalitis, Parkinsons Disease)
Rainman (autistic disorder)
Away From Her (Alzheimers Disease)
M (psychotic disorder)
The Diving Bell and The Butterfly (stroke)

No, that's not right, either. "Neurocinema" has a short (and controversial) Wikipedia page:

Neurocinema is a new filmmaking process that studies a viewer's sensorimotor, cognitive, and affective response to film stimuli. Researchers use technologies such as functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) to measure changes in activity in parts of the brain,electroencephalography (EEG) to measure activity in specific regional spectra of the brain response, and/or sensors to measure changes in one's physiological state (heart rate, respiratory rate, galvanic skin response) to learn exactly what scenes excite or disinterest the viewer.

The entry was originally marked for deletion on Sept. 25 (as a neologism with little coverage), but apparently it was reinstated after articles appeared in Wired.com and CNN.com. This minimalistic and poorly written entry is also a source of free publicity:

Peter Katz and MindSign Neuromarketing have done early studies into neurocinema that Wired.com and CNN has covered.

Dutifully following the links, here's what we learn from the CNN article:

Brain scans gauge horror flick fear factor
LONDON, England (CNN) -- Film producer Peter Katz doesn't just want his horror movies to scare you. He wants to pinpoint how frightened you are down to an exact moment in a scene.
To do that, he recently teamed up with researchers and used MRI scans of brain function to determine the degree of fright caused by certain scenes from his latest horror flick, "Pop Skull."
For the experiment, researchers at functional MRI research facility Mindsign Neuromarketing, based in San Diego, California, scanned the brain activity of a subject [NOTE: my emphasis] while she watched two scenes of his movie. Analyzing the data from the scan, they were able to pinpoint the exact moments when her brain was lit up with fear.
. . .
During Katz's experiment, researchers analyzed scans to identify the exact moment during each film scene that the viewer's amygdala -- the part of the brain linked to several emotions, including fear -- was activated, and to what degree.

Let's see where they went wrong scientifically: (1) Calling one subject "an experiment" -- was he making a movie just for her? (2) Saying fMRI can pinpoint the exact moment of anything -- there's a significant delay between initial neural firing and the peak of the hemodynamic response, which is estimated using a procedure that is not trivial for something as complex as an emotional response. (3) Using amygdala activity as a proxy for fear and thereby committing the cardinal sin of reverse inference (one cannot directly infer emotional state from the observed pattern of brain activity) -- didn't they learn from the op-ed neuroimaging fiasco in the New York Times ("This Is Your Brain on Politics")?

Then at Wired, Neurocinema Aims to Change the Way Movies are Made: [NOTE: or hyped]

Recently they finished their first full test with results that could change the way films are made. Yes, someone had to lie still in an MRI machine. The objective of the research, specifically, was to determine the brain response in the amygdala to watching scenes from the horror film Pop Skull. For those that don’t know, the amygdala is the emotional center of the brain. It’s involved in feelings of disgust, anger, lust and fear — all emotions especially elicited during a horror film. [NOTE: because it doesn't matter if your audience is feeling horny or disgusted instead of scared.]
. . .
For two sessions of 48 seconds and 68 seconds, a 24-year-old female watched two scenes from the movie while being scanned in a Siemens 3T MRI scanner. With a 20-second break in between three viewings of each scene (to refocus her eyes to center), the data was converted into a BrainMovie... and analyzed by the team at MindSign. What they saw (and what you can see in the movie) is that for most of the two movie scenes, the amygdala lit up like a Christmas tree out of fear. This activity was pinpointed to the frame, the exact scene and action that registered the response. For instance, “The scariest moment in Scene 1 came when the hand reaches further around the corner.” It is that precise.

Oh please spare me. I watched the BrainMovie and there were implausible jumps in activity from one frame to the next (compare "scary hand" at 2:42 to "scary hand again" at 2:48). Plus, don't you lose the element of surprise the second time you watch a specific scene? Who is going to see the infamous Alien chestburster scene the same way twice (i.e., 20 seconds after the first viewing)?

Then the Wired author interviewed film maker Katz and Dr. David Hubbard, "a board-certified neurologist who is the leading neurologist on the project." Although Dr. Hubbard has published respectable work on pain and headache using EMG, he has no papers at all using fMRI. Nonetheless, he is founder and chairman of The Hubbard Foundation for fMRI Research, "a charitable foundation supporting research and education in applied psychophysiology." He is also managing director of the Applied fMRI Institute, which presumably charges customers for "neuropsychological testing, neuromarketing and neurocinema, traditional academic research studies and explorations of meditation." No conflict of interest there. Oh wait, his education credits include STUDENT, Cognitive Science, University of California, San Diego, 2003-present. Good to know he's getting on the job fMRI training. This brain image doesn't instill a lot of confidence however given the extensive deactivation occurring outside the brain.

My final Google query was for MindSign Neuromarketing, whose motto is "Don’t rely on a focus group, or consumer’s ability to express their opinion about a product, let their minds speak for themselves." The organizational structure of MindSign was opaque at first, but I eventually discovered their scanning is done at "the cutting-edge Applied fMRI Institute, the only privately owned, market-friendly fMRI facility in the world."

In my view, the most successful aspect of this entire enterprise has been a boatload of uncritical coverage from the popular press.

For balanced blog coverage of the hype, see Neurovid: Neurocinema. And a neuromarketer presents a Scary Idea: Forget Focus Groups.

- Some Terrifying Psychology Links For Halloween
Wishing you a thriller of a Halloween! How to make a Halloween brain cake (ht @mocost). What do young children know about managing fear? How to make a zombie brain (See also this related video). The Lure of Horror, where I explore horror's...

- The Hyperscanning Of 'paranormal Activity': A Neurocinematic Study Of Collective Fear
Still from the promotional trailer for that viral movie phenomenon, Paranormal Activity. Not since The Blair Witch Project (1999)1 ten years ago (in the BT [Before Twitter] dark ages) has there been such a grassroots "underground" buzz surrounding a...

- Carnival Of Souls
The Synapse No. 3 (a neuroscience carnival) is now available for your reading pleasure at The Neurophilosopher's Blog! July 23, 2006 The Haunting By JOHN HODGMAN New York Times Magazine . . . Horror, like comedy, has always been something of a reptilian-brain...

- Neuromarketing And "the Super Bowl Brain Scans"
This one's from Vaughan at Mind Hacks, who does a superb job of debunking this ridiculous exercise in publicity and hype. His post is reprinted below. No additional comments from The Neurocritic are needed. The 'complete results' from the...

- Emotional Control In The Brain??
Again from the mailing list of friends of colleagues, etc. Isn't the Internet grand? Anyway ... Emotional Control Circuit Of Brain's Fear Response Discovered (press release) Source: Columbia University Medical Center Date: September 22, 2006 Columbia...

Neuroscience