Neuroscience
The way burglars select houses to target, and how they search once inside, reveal evidence of an expert mind at work. That’s according to Claire Nee and Amy Meenaghan who say the finding has implications for crime prevention.
Nee and Meenaghan interviewed 50 jailed burglars, all of whom had committed at least 20 burglaries in the last three years; half had committed more than 100.
In more scrupulous walks of life, a person is recognised as an expert when they no longer need to deliberately concentrate on what they’re doing – instead their performance becomes automatic and fast, freeing their mind up for other things. The researchers found this matched the way many of the burglars described searching inside houses. Over three quarters of them described searching as relatively routine, and 15 of them actually used terms such as ‘automatic’ and ‘instinctive’.
“People leave things in the same basic locations…could have done it with my eyes shut”, said one burglar. “…got to be totally focused on outside noises, sometimes sixth sense, the search is automatic”, said another. Two thirds of the burglars described the same search pattern, beginning with the master bedroom and finishing with the kitchen.
There was also evidence of expertise in the stereotyped way the burglars reported checking for relative wealth, occupancy, access and security when selecting houses to target.
“All in all, the processes involved in executing a burglary worth several hundred pounds in around 20 minutes strongly suggest the use of expertise in the burglar”, the researchers concluded. They added that recognising this fact could help burglary prevention. “There may be some situational crime prevention mileage in confounding burglars’ expectations by altering the usual internal layout of properties”, they said. “Expert burglars appear to be highly habit driven, and crime prevention specialists should capitalise on this”.
___________________________________
Nee, C. & Meenaghan, A. (2006). Expert decision making in burglars. British Journal of Criminology, 46, 935-949.
Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.
- Does A Murderer's Crime-scene Behaviour Echo His Criminal History?
In the old days of criminal profiling, a psychologist would study the idiosyncrasies of a crime scene with the expert-eye of an art collector inspecting a painting of unknown provenance. They'd draw on their clinical and forensic knowledge to help...
- The Fingerprint Of Where And When A Burglary Is Committed
In the land of fiction, it's the criminal's modus operandi - his method of entry, his taste for certain jewellery and so forth - that can be used by detectives to identify his handiwork. The reality according to a new analysis of solved burglaries...
- Extras
Eye-catching studies that didn't make the final cut: Less than human? How we perceive members of the out-group versus our in-group. An account of what motivates people to become suicide bombers. Staring at a moving stimulus like a waterfall and then...
- Extras
Eye-catching studies that didn't make the final cut: Australian psychologists ask whether it's time for a professional oath in psychology. Jealousy. Sherlock Holmes and expertise: "Although nearly 120-years-old, Conan Doyle's books show remarkable...
- Geniuses In The News
Recent issues of both Scientific American & Wired have featured articles about geniuses / expert minds, from two different perspectives. The August, 2006 issue of Scientific American looks at The Expert Mind (full article online!) from the perspective...
Neuroscience
The expert mind of the burglar
The way burglars select houses to target, and how they search once inside, reveal evidence of an expert mind at work. That’s according to Claire Nee and Amy Meenaghan who say the finding has implications for crime prevention.Nee and Meenaghan interviewed 50 jailed burglars, all of whom had committed at least 20 burglaries in the last three years; half had committed more than 100.
In more scrupulous walks of life, a person is recognised as an expert when they no longer need to deliberately concentrate on what they’re doing – instead their performance becomes automatic and fast, freeing their mind up for other things. The researchers found this matched the way many of the burglars described searching inside houses. Over three quarters of them described searching as relatively routine, and 15 of them actually used terms such as ‘automatic’ and ‘instinctive’.
“People leave things in the same basic locations…could have done it with my eyes shut”, said one burglar. “…got to be totally focused on outside noises, sometimes sixth sense, the search is automatic”, said another. Two thirds of the burglars described the same search pattern, beginning with the master bedroom and finishing with the kitchen.
There was also evidence of expertise in the stereotyped way the burglars reported checking for relative wealth, occupancy, access and security when selecting houses to target.
“All in all, the processes involved in executing a burglary worth several hundred pounds in around 20 minutes strongly suggest the use of expertise in the burglar”, the researchers concluded. They added that recognising this fact could help burglary prevention. “There may be some situational crime prevention mileage in confounding burglars’ expectations by altering the usual internal layout of properties”, they said. “Expert burglars appear to be highly habit driven, and crime prevention specialists should capitalise on this”.
___________________________________
Nee, C. & Meenaghan, A. (2006). Expert decision making in burglars. British Journal of Criminology, 46, 935-949.
Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.
- Does A Murderer's Crime-scene Behaviour Echo His Criminal History?
In the old days of criminal profiling, a psychologist would study the idiosyncrasies of a crime scene with the expert-eye of an art collector inspecting a painting of unknown provenance. They'd draw on their clinical and forensic knowledge to help...
- The Fingerprint Of Where And When A Burglary Is Committed
In the land of fiction, it's the criminal's modus operandi - his method of entry, his taste for certain jewellery and so forth - that can be used by detectives to identify his handiwork. The reality according to a new analysis of solved burglaries...
- Extras
Eye-catching studies that didn't make the final cut: Less than human? How we perceive members of the out-group versus our in-group. An account of what motivates people to become suicide bombers. Staring at a moving stimulus like a waterfall and then...
- Extras
Eye-catching studies that didn't make the final cut: Australian psychologists ask whether it's time for a professional oath in psychology. Jealousy. Sherlock Holmes and expertise: "Although nearly 120-years-old, Conan Doyle's books show remarkable...
- Geniuses In The News
Recent issues of both Scientific American & Wired have featured articles about geniuses / expert minds, from two different perspectives. The August, 2006 issue of Scientific American looks at The Expert Mind (full article online!) from the perspective...