Neuroscience
Plenty of research has shown that some stereotypes are not only offensive, they can also have a detrimental effect on people's behaviour.
For example, women's maths performance suffers after they are reminded of the stereotype that men are better than women at maths.
Now Armand Chatard and colleagues have taken this line of research a step further by demonstrating that being reminded of gender stereotypes can distort students' memories of their prior exam performance.
An initial study with 73 high school students (34 boys) showed that those students who more strongly endorsed gender stereotypes in relation to maths and the arts, subsequently showed more biased recall of their past exam performance. That is, girls who endorsed the stereotypes underestimated their past maths performance, while boys who endorsed the stereotypes tended to underestimate their past arts performance.
A second study with 64 high school students gave some a highly salient reminder of gender stereotypes - that is, they rated their agreement with statements like "Men are gifted in mathematics" and "Women are gifted in the arts", before rating their own abilities. Others were given what was considered a weaker reminder of gender stereotypes - they rated their own performance first, before evaluating men and women in general. Finally, all the students recalled their past exam performance.
Girls given a more salient reminder of gender stereotypes underestimated their actual past maths exam performance while boys in this condition overestimated their maths performance. No such difference was observed in the weak reminder condition. Regarding the arts, all students overestimated their performance, but among those given a salient reminder of stereotypes, the girls overestimated their arts performance more, and the boys far less.
The researchers said these findings could have real world implications: "It is possible that women are less likely to embrace scientific careers than men because gender stereotypes lead them to underestimate their past achievement."
_________________________________
Chatard, A., Guimond, S. & Selimbegovic, L. (2007). "How good are you in math?" The effect of gender stereotypes on students' recollection of their school marks. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 43, 1017-1024.
Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.
Photo credit: Alexander Redmon
- Why Are Boys Better Than Girls At Maths In Some Countries But Not Others?
There are many reasons for the paucity of women in science and technology careers, but arguably one early contributing factor is the relatively weaker performance of girls in maths at school, compared with boys. Is this because girls are inherently poorer...
- Gender Differences In Superstition - Men Are Influenced By Good Omens, Women By The Unlucky
Imagine taking a seat for a university exam and seeing that your seat number is unlucky. Would it bother you? A new study by Maria De Paola and her colleagues explored this question in a field study with over 700 Italian students. Sixty-one of the students...
- Women's True Maths Skills Unlocked By Pretending To Be Someone Else
There's an unfounded gender stereotype that says women aren't as good at maths as men. Reminding them of this prior to a maths task usually undermines their performance - just one example of a harmful phenomenon known as stereotype threat. Research...
- Sitting Upright Is Psychologically Good For Men, But Is It Good For Women?
Stop slouching! Sitting with an upright posture can have a positive effect on your mood and improve your performance at a maths test, but only if you are male. That's the implication of a study by Tomi-Ann Roberts and Yousef Arefi-Afshar at Colorado...
- Hey Girl, You're Really Bad At Math!
Right? Girls are bad at math, aren't they? Former Harvard president Larry Summers seem to think so... According to Wikipedia, Stereotype threat is the fear that one's behavior will confirm an existing stereotype of a group with which one identifies....
Neuroscience
Gender stereotypes can distort our memories
Plenty of research has shown that some stereotypes are not only offensive, they can also have a detrimental effect on people's behaviour.For example, women's maths performance suffers after they are reminded of the stereotype that men are better than women at maths.
Now Armand Chatard and colleagues have taken this line of research a step further by demonstrating that being reminded of gender stereotypes can distort students' memories of their prior exam performance.
An initial study with 73 high school students (34 boys) showed that those students who more strongly endorsed gender stereotypes in relation to maths and the arts, subsequently showed more biased recall of their past exam performance. That is, girls who endorsed the stereotypes underestimated their past maths performance, while boys who endorsed the stereotypes tended to underestimate their past arts performance.
A second study with 64 high school students gave some a highly salient reminder of gender stereotypes - that is, they rated their agreement with statements like "Men are gifted in mathematics" and "Women are gifted in the arts", before rating their own abilities. Others were given what was considered a weaker reminder of gender stereotypes - they rated their own performance first, before evaluating men and women in general. Finally, all the students recalled their past exam performance.
Girls given a more salient reminder of gender stereotypes underestimated their actual past maths exam performance while boys in this condition overestimated their maths performance. No such difference was observed in the weak reminder condition. Regarding the arts, all students overestimated their performance, but among those given a salient reminder of stereotypes, the girls overestimated their arts performance more, and the boys far less.
The researchers said these findings could have real world implications: "It is possible that women are less likely to embrace scientific careers than men because gender stereotypes lead them to underestimate their past achievement."
_________________________________
Chatard, A., Guimond, S. & Selimbegovic, L. (2007). "How good are you in math?" The effect of gender stereotypes on students' recollection of their school marks. Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 43, 1017-1024.
Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.
Photo credit: Alexander Redmon
- Why Are Boys Better Than Girls At Maths In Some Countries But Not Others?
There are many reasons for the paucity of women in science and technology careers, but arguably one early contributing factor is the relatively weaker performance of girls in maths at school, compared with boys. Is this because girls are inherently poorer...
- Gender Differences In Superstition - Men Are Influenced By Good Omens, Women By The Unlucky
Imagine taking a seat for a university exam and seeing that your seat number is unlucky. Would it bother you? A new study by Maria De Paola and her colleagues explored this question in a field study with over 700 Italian students. Sixty-one of the students...
- Women's True Maths Skills Unlocked By Pretending To Be Someone Else
There's an unfounded gender stereotype that says women aren't as good at maths as men. Reminding them of this prior to a maths task usually undermines their performance - just one example of a harmful phenomenon known as stereotype threat. Research...
- Sitting Upright Is Psychologically Good For Men, But Is It Good For Women?
Stop slouching! Sitting with an upright posture can have a positive effect on your mood and improve your performance at a maths test, but only if you are male. That's the implication of a study by Tomi-Ann Roberts and Yousef Arefi-Afshar at Colorado...
- Hey Girl, You're Really Bad At Math!
Right? Girls are bad at math, aren't they? Former Harvard president Larry Summers seem to think so... According to Wikipedia, Stereotype threat is the fear that one's behavior will confirm an existing stereotype of a group with which one identifies....