Neuroscience
In one of the first ever studies to simultaneously scan the brains of two people, researchers at the Human Neuroimaging Lab in Texas have furthered our understanding of how the brain represents trust.
Forty-eight pairs of participants took part in an economics game. Groundbreaking 'hyperscanning' software meant that while one person lay in a scanner in Texas, their partner lay in a similar machine hundreds of miles away in California, and yet their brain images could be analysed together.
One partner was given $20 and was the investor. Each round they chose how much money to pass to their partner, the 'trustee'. Both players knew that according to the rules, the money tripled once it was passed to the trustee. The trustee then chose how much of that profit to share back with the investor before the next round began. There were ten rounds.
When an investor raised their next investment despite the trustee having been unfair the previous round, the researchers found that the trustee's brain then reacted in a characteristic way. Their caudate nucleus - a neural area well-connected to the brain's reward pathways - became more active, probably reflecting their increasing 'trust' in the investor's good will. Activity in this region of their brain then also predicted how generously they shared that round's profit.
Moreover, as the game wore on, this differential activity in the caudate began occurring earlier by several seconds, suggesting the trustee was starting to anticipate a generous investment (or not) from their partner as they learned their playing style.
The researchers said: "Taken together, these results suggest that the head of the caudate nucleus receives or computes information about (i) the fairness of a social partner's decision, and (ii) the intention to repay that decision with trust".
_________________________________
King-Casas, B., Tomlin, D., Anen, C., Camerer, C.F. Quartz, S.R. & Montague, P.R. (2005). Getting to know you: reputation and trust in a two-person economic exchange. Science, 308, 78-83.
Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.
- The Pursuit Of Power
Everyone knows that power is seductive, but is it power over others that we crave or power over our own actions and decisions? To find out, Marius Van Dijke and Matthijs Poppe devised a financial game in which hundreds of undergrads took turns with a...
- Who Can You Trust?
As a sequel to the "Trust Your Insula" theme from last time (i.e., Borderline … feels like I'm goin' to lose my mind), The Neurocritic has consulted the BrainMap database, which revealed that the anterior insula is activated in a wide variety...
- Borderline … Feels Like I'm Goin' To Lose My Mind
No, the 80s Madonna song isn't really about Borderline Personality Disorder. But a new study in Science (King-Casas et al., 2008) makes me feel like I'm goin' to lose my mind. Or more precisely, makes me exhibit two of nine DSM-IV-TR criteria:...
- Neuroeconomics And The Cingulate Cortex
Anatomy of Give and Take Economic theory goes only so far in explaining why people buy, sell, save or trust. Scientists are looking inside the mind for answers. By Robert Lee Hotz, Times Staff Writer The Los Angeles Times 18 March 2005 HOUSTON — The...
- Trust = Love?
An article in a recent issue of Science suggests that the emotion of trust "lives" near the emotion of love in the brain. Researchers at the Baylor College of Medicine Human Neuroimaging Laboratoryused fMRI imaging and an investment game to pinpoint a...
Neuroscience
Trust in the brain
In one of the first ever studies to simultaneously scan the brains of two people, researchers at the Human Neuroimaging Lab in Texas have furthered our understanding of how the brain represents trust.
Forty-eight pairs of participants took part in an economics game. Groundbreaking 'hyperscanning' software meant that while one person lay in a scanner in Texas, their partner lay in a similar machine hundreds of miles away in California, and yet their brain images could be analysed together.
One partner was given $20 and was the investor. Each round they chose how much money to pass to their partner, the 'trustee'. Both players knew that according to the rules, the money tripled once it was passed to the trustee. The trustee then chose how much of that profit to share back with the investor before the next round began. There were ten rounds.
When an investor raised their next investment despite the trustee having been unfair the previous round, the researchers found that the trustee's brain then reacted in a characteristic way. Their caudate nucleus - a neural area well-connected to the brain's reward pathways - became more active, probably reflecting their increasing 'trust' in the investor's good will. Activity in this region of their brain then also predicted how generously they shared that round's profit.
Moreover, as the game wore on, this differential activity in the caudate began occurring earlier by several seconds, suggesting the trustee was starting to anticipate a generous investment (or not) from their partner as they learned their playing style.
The researchers said: "Taken together, these results suggest that the head of the caudate nucleus receives or computes information about (i) the fairness of a social partner's decision, and (ii) the intention to repay that decision with trust".
_________________________________
King-Casas, B., Tomlin, D., Anen, C., Camerer, C.F. Quartz, S.R. & Montague, P.R. (2005). Getting to know you: reputation and trust in a two-person economic exchange. Science, 308, 78-83.
Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.
- The Pursuit Of Power
Everyone knows that power is seductive, but is it power over others that we crave or power over our own actions and decisions? To find out, Marius Van Dijke and Matthijs Poppe devised a financial game in which hundreds of undergrads took turns with a...
- Who Can You Trust?
As a sequel to the "Trust Your Insula" theme from last time (i.e., Borderline … feels like I'm goin' to lose my mind), The Neurocritic has consulted the BrainMap database, which revealed that the anterior insula is activated in a wide variety...
- Borderline … Feels Like I'm Goin' To Lose My Mind
No, the 80s Madonna song isn't really about Borderline Personality Disorder. But a new study in Science (King-Casas et al., 2008) makes me feel like I'm goin' to lose my mind. Or more precisely, makes me exhibit two of nine DSM-IV-TR criteria:...
- Neuroeconomics And The Cingulate Cortex
Anatomy of Give and Take Economic theory goes only so far in explaining why people buy, sell, save or trust. Scientists are looking inside the mind for answers. By Robert Lee Hotz, Times Staff Writer The Los Angeles Times 18 March 2005 HOUSTON — The...
- Trust = Love?
An article in a recent issue of Science suggests that the emotion of trust "lives" near the emotion of love in the brain. Researchers at the Baylor College of Medicine Human Neuroimaging Laboratoryused fMRI imaging and an investment game to pinpoint a...