More Truly, Truly Outrageous Medical Hypotheses
Neuroscience

More Truly, Truly Outrageous Medical Hypotheses




For the gift that keeps on giving, peruse the table of contents for the August 2008 issue of the Journal of Medical Hypotheses. Neurotopia (version 2.0) did, and the result is:
Screw the sudafed: When your nose ain't great, masturbate!

I'm starting to think it must be a LOT of fun to be the editor of the Journal of Medical Hypotheses. First there was the one about groaning and hyperventilation decreasing blood to the cortex and enhancing the sexual experience, and now this...

Zarrintan, S "Ejaculation as a potential treatment of nasal congestion in mature males" The Journal of Medical Hypotheses, 71(2), 2008.

Oh man, this one's so good I almost just want to quote it verbatim. But I won't.

But I will (Zarrintan 2008, page 308):
The emission phase of the ejaculatory reflex is under control of the sympathetic nervous system, while the ejaculatory phase is under control of a spinal reflex at the level of the spinal nerves S2-4 via the pudendal nerve. A refractory period succeeds the ejaculation, in which the sympathetic nervous system counteracts the effects of the parasympathetic nervous system. As it is seen, ejaculation can be used as a potential treatment of nasal congestion because its emission phase provides a sympathetic stimulation and subsequent vasoconstriction and nasal decongestion.
Even better is a letter in reply to this fabulous article, as noted by The Lay Scientist:
WARNING: Ejaculation as a Treatment for Nasal Congestion is Inconvenient, Unreliable and Potentially Hazardous!

...the journal has now published a letter by Mohammad Fakhree angrily rejecting the claims, in the prelude to what could be the biggest medical controversy since MMR.

...Fakhree is far from convinced, citing a whole range of objections.

"First notable thing is that the process which leads to ejaculation makes significant changes in blood pressure and heart rate which can be as harmful as decongestants side effects."

Basically, you need to be fit. You don't want to end up like the stereotypical older guy who's shagged to death by his nubile younger lover. Especially if you don't even get the shagging part beforehand. That would suck. It's not even dignified... imagine how you'd be found?

Another consideration is that, in some males there are limitations in the number of ejaculation per day and also between two ejaculations.

I suspect, actually, that applies to all males. It's a penis, not a machine gun.

Furthermore there are some limitations in using of ejaculation or masturbation as treatment of nasal congestion such as not being applicable out of home and not having any sex partner.

Frankly, it's news to me that I needed to have a sex partner for masturbation, that kind of being the whole point of Britain's #1 hobby in the first place. If I was with a "sex partner", then I would be having sex.
What an epic battle of scientific titans! But as an astute commenter noted:
Having read both articles, I noticed that both Zarrintan and Fakhree are from the same city (perhaps the same university)! Which leads me to think whether this little handbag fight may in fact be a lovers' squabble?





- Noxious Mystery Substance Released Into The Third Ventricle Is The Cause Of Depression!
The Ventricles of the Brain (Ross & Wilson) You can always count on the journal Medical Hypotheses (published by Elsevier) for a good laugh. The Editor-in-Chief (Bruce G. Charlton) accepts all sorts of completely speculative crackpot articles. Who...

- Snotty Or Nice?
Bhutta MF, Maxwell H. Sneezing induced by sexual ideation or orgasm: an under-reported phenomenon. J R Soc Med. 2008 Dec;101(12):587-91. We describe a hitherto under-recognized curious response in some individuals: of sneezing in response either to sexual...

- The Pseudonymous ‘quant Bloggers’
While writing the previous post, this article in the October 2008 issue of the Journal of Medical Hypotheses caught my eye: Editorial Figureheads, ghost-writers and pseudonymous quant bloggers: The recent evolution of authorship in science publishing...

- Upcoming: Alzheimer's: Fda Advisory Committee Meeting (20-21 January 2011)
From the FDA (.pdfs of briefing material is available at the link below): January 20-21, 2011: Peripheral and Central Nervous System Drugs Advisory Committee Meeting Announcement Read the full announcementAgenda "On January 20, 2011, the committee will...

- Epilepsy Surgery
The 26 April 2005 issue of the Canadian Medical Association Journal includes the free full-text contents of a teaching case report on the topic of surgery in epilepsy: Jorge G. Burneo and Richard S. McLachlan (2005). When should surgery be considered...



Neuroscience








.