Neuroscience
After a social interaction, participants rate people who mimicked their movements or speech more favourably than they rate people who didn’t mimic them, even if they were unaware of the mimicry – a phenomenon that’s been dubbed the chameleon effect. Now Jeremy Bailenson and Nick Yee at Stanford University have shown this social effect of mimicry still occurs even when people are mimicked by what they know is a digital, computerised ‘agent’ seen in a virtual reality graphics environment, rather than by another human.
Sixty-nine male and female student participants wore a virtual reality helmet that displayed a 3-D image of the head and shoulders of a digital agent (see picture). For half the participants, the digital agent precisely mimicked their head movements with a four-second delay. For the other control participants, the digital agent did not mimic their movements, but instead moved its head as the previous participant had done. Eight participants detected they were being mimicked and were omitted from the analysis.
The digital agent spoke for 195 seconds about a proposed university campus security policy. After the experiment, all the participants answered questions about what the agent had said and what they thought of the agent. The digital agent was rated as more persuasive and likeable by participants whose head movements it had mimicked than by participants it didn’t mimic, thus suggesting the chameleon effect works for computers too.
As electronic communications become more sophisticated the researchers said their finding suggested digital mimicry could be used to manipulate and persuade. “Whether in immersive virtual reality, on-line chat rooms, or video games, algorithmic mimics may become commonplace, with agents mimicking users as frequently as their designers want, or as subtly or as obviously as they are programmed to do”, they said.
_________________________________
Bailenson, J.N. & Yee, N. (2005). Digital chameleons. Automatic assimilation of nonverbal gestures in immersive virtual reality environments. Psychological Science, 16, 814-819.
Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.
- For Mimicry To Flatter, It's All About The Body Part, Not The Action
We like people more when they mimic us. But only up to a point. If mimicry becomes too obvious, it can backfire, becoming mockery. A new study asks just how much imitation is enough to trigger benefits. Does the mimicker need to copy every action, or...
- Mimicry Improves Women's Speed-dating Success
Women hoping to appeal to speed-dating partners should try subtly mimicking the words and body-language of their dates. That's according to Nicholas Gueguen whose new study shows that women who mimic are rated by men as more sexually attractive. Gueguen...
- Walking In Other People's Digital Shoes Could Back-fire
They say you should walk a mile in a person's shoes before judging them. Virtual reality technology offers this possibility by allowing us to control a digital representation of another person. Unfortunately, the first ever investigation of racial...
- Psychological Research In Virtual Worlds
Nick Yee of Stanford University, with the fourth article in our series of guest features. Virtual worlds (such as World of Warcraft and Second Life) have received a great deal of media and academic attention recently. While these virtual communities provide...
- Get Out Of My Cyberspace!
If you thought online virtual worlds would be an easy-going utopia where players cast aside their awkward real-world inhibitions, think again. Online games like Second Life allow people to adopt an alternative identity and interact with other players...
Neuroscience
Mimicry the best form of flattery for computers too
After a social interaction, participants rate people who mimicked their movements or speech more favourably than they rate people who didn’t mimic them, even if they were unaware of the mimicry – a phenomenon that’s been dubbed the chameleon effect. Now Jeremy Bailenson and Nick Yee at Stanford University have shown this social effect of mimicry still occurs even when people are mimicked by what they know is a digital, computerised ‘agent’ seen in a virtual reality graphics environment, rather than by another human.Sixty-nine male and female student participants wore a virtual reality helmet that displayed a 3-D image of the head and shoulders of a digital agent (see picture). For half the participants, the digital agent precisely mimicked their head movements with a four-second delay. For the other control participants, the digital agent did not mimic their movements, but instead moved its head as the previous participant had done. Eight participants detected they were being mimicked and were omitted from the analysis.
The digital agent spoke for 195 seconds about a proposed university campus security policy. After the experiment, all the participants answered questions about what the agent had said and what they thought of the agent. The digital agent was rated as more persuasive and likeable by participants whose head movements it had mimicked than by participants it didn’t mimic, thus suggesting the chameleon effect works for computers too.
As electronic communications become more sophisticated the researchers said their finding suggested digital mimicry could be used to manipulate and persuade. “Whether in immersive virtual reality, on-line chat rooms, or video games, algorithmic mimics may become commonplace, with agents mimicking users as frequently as their designers want, or as subtly or as obviously as they are programmed to do”, they said.
_________________________________
Bailenson, J.N. & Yee, N. (2005). Digital chameleons. Automatic assimilation of nonverbal gestures in immersive virtual reality environments. Psychological Science, 16, 814-819.
Post written by Christian Jarrett (@psych_writer) for the BPS Research Digest.
- For Mimicry To Flatter, It's All About The Body Part, Not The Action
We like people more when they mimic us. But only up to a point. If mimicry becomes too obvious, it can backfire, becoming mockery. A new study asks just how much imitation is enough to trigger benefits. Does the mimicker need to copy every action, or...
- Mimicry Improves Women's Speed-dating Success
Women hoping to appeal to speed-dating partners should try subtly mimicking the words and body-language of their dates. That's according to Nicholas Gueguen whose new study shows that women who mimic are rated by men as more sexually attractive. Gueguen...
- Walking In Other People's Digital Shoes Could Back-fire
They say you should walk a mile in a person's shoes before judging them. Virtual reality technology offers this possibility by allowing us to control a digital representation of another person. Unfortunately, the first ever investigation of racial...
- Psychological Research In Virtual Worlds
Nick Yee of Stanford University, with the fourth article in our series of guest features. Virtual worlds (such as World of Warcraft and Second Life) have received a great deal of media and academic attention recently. While these virtual communities provide...
- Get Out Of My Cyberspace!
If you thought online virtual worlds would be an easy-going utopia where players cast aside their awkward real-world inhibitions, think again. Online games like Second Life allow people to adopt an alternative identity and interact with other players...